Direct answer

Work from the two agreements and the job record, protect the sub first, and keep your voice down.

You brought a good subcontractor onto your client's job. The work went well, and now you learn, from the sub if you are lucky, that the client has approached them directly about the next piece of work, cutting you out of a chain you built. The instinct is to fire off an angry message within the hour. Resist it. Almost every move that feels satisfying in this situation damages the wrong relationship: the sub did not create this problem by being approached, and a client conversation held in anger, claiming rights you have not checked, can turn a recoverable situation into a lost client and a lost sub at the same time. The order that works is slower and colder. First, protect the sub relationship, because a sub who tells you about approaches is worth more than any single job. Second, read what your two agreements actually say before claiming anything, because the paper decides whether you hold a breach claim, a fee claim, or a commercial conversation. Third, have that conversation with the client calmly, in writing, anchored in the agreements and in the job record of who was engaged for what and by whom. This page walks that order, with the exact wording for the client message.

See the instrument first: the live demo runs one real call and hands you its verifiable receipt, no signup.

Updated November 22, 2026. First published November 22, 2026. The records quoted below are real and public, read back from the live service on November 22, 2026.

Step 1. Slow down and separate the three relationships in front of you

There are three relationships here, and they need three different responses. You and the client: a commercial relationship that may have been bent, and possibly broken, depending on the paper. You and the sub: your supply chain and your reputation in miniature, and the relationship most easily destroyed by a misdirected reaction. The sub and the client: a contact you created by introducing them on your job, which is exactly why the situation stings, and exactly why what happens next should be governed by what was agreed when you made that introduction. Notice what is not on the list: the sub's loyalty is not the question. Being approached is not a betrayal, listening politely is not a betrayal, and in many cases the sub has already done the most loyal thing available by telling you it happened. Treat the approach as information about the client, not as a verdict on the sub, and let your first actions protect the asset you can least replace. Firms lose good subs in this moment far more often than they lose clients: the client was testing a boundary, the firm exploded at everyone, and the sub quietly decided that working through that firm came with drama they never signed up for.

Step 2. Check what each agreement actually says before claiming a breach

Before any message to the client, read two documents. Your client agreement: look for the clauses that govern this exact move, wording about engaging your subcontractors or introduced personnel directly, non-circumvention or introduction terms, a fee for direct engagement, or a period after the job during which direct engagement routes through you. Your sub agreement: look for what it says about accepting direct work from clients you introduced, and about telling you when an approach happens. Then sort what you find into three honest piles. Pile one: a clause covers this, in which case your client message can point to the clause, calmly, by its terms. Pile two: the sub agreement covers the sub's side but the client agreement is silent, in which case your conversation with the client is commercial, about the value of the introduction and the working arrangement, not about a broken promise. Pile three: nothing in writing covers it, in which case you almost certainly have no breach to claim, and claiming one anyway costs you credibility you will need. In piles two and three the remedy is forward-looking: price the introduction properly from now on and fix the paper in step 6. Say only what the paper supports, and the conversation stays professional whichever pile you are in.

Step 3. Protect the sub relationship first: no punishment for being approached

Your first message in this whole situation goes to the sub, not the client, and its content is short: thanks for telling me, you have done nothing wrong, your current work and its payment continue exactly as agreed, and I will handle the client side. Say it even if the sub did not tell you and you heard it elsewhere, adjusted honestly: you have heard an approach was made, you do not hold it against them, and the door stays open. Never punish the sub for being approached: no cut hours, no cooled relationship, no demand that they refuse all direct work forever unless a written term you both agreed actually says so, and even then the enforcement conversation belongs with the party who agreed the term with you. The economics are simple. A sub who reports approaches is an early warning system for your whole client base, and that system only keeps reporting while reporting is safe. A sub who gets burned for honesty stops reporting, and the next approach, from a less scrupulous client, happens entirely in the dark. Protect the channel first; the client conversation can wait a day while you read the paper, and it will be a better conversation for the wait.

Step 4. Let the job record state who was engaged for what, and by whom

The factual spine of the client conversation is the introduction itself: this sub, brought onto this job, by you, for this scope, on these dates. Memory argues about that spine surprisingly often once money is involved, the client recalling that they had somehow always known the sub, the timeline blurring in everyone's favour. A job record made as the work happened does not blur. The record format is AER-1, published as an IETF Internet-Draft (draft-zambo-aer1-26), created by Brennan Zambo, and each step carries a verifiable receipt: a receipt proves the saved result was not changed since it was saved. The two public records below show the states such a record carries:

Accepted: the decision is on the record

Pending: checked, and still waiting on a decision

Read the accepted record for the facts it pins down: work saved step by step, 4 steps checked, then a decision recorded as decided_by client at 2026-10-16T14:31:51.146Z, release state ok_to_release. Who delivered, who decided, and when are record facts, not recollections. The pending record, 5 steps checked and on hold, shows the same pinning before any decision lands. On your job, the equivalent facts are the ones the client conversation needs: the sub's scope sits on the record under your engagement, dated as it happened, so the sentence the introduction came through you is something you can show rather than assert. Bring the record to the conversation as a link, briefly, without theatre: it quietly removes the factual argument so the real conversation, about terms and price, can happen.

Step 5. Send the client a calm written response, anchored in the agreement and the record

The message, word for word in shape, adjusted to the pile your paper check found: I understand you have spoken with [sub] about [the next work] directly. [Sub] came onto this project through my firm, for [scope], and the record of that engagement is at [link]. Under our agreement, [the clause: direct engagement of subcontractors I introduce is routed through me / carries the introduction fee of X], so the clean way to run this piece is [through my firm on the usual terms / with the introduction fee settled first], and I am happy to set it up today. If the paper is silent, the middle sentences change honestly: there is no clause covering it, the introduction and the working relationship run through my firm, and if you would like to work with [sub] directly going forward, the fair shape is an introduction fee of [amount], after which I wish you both well on it. Notice what the shape never does: it never accuses the client of stealing, never threatens, never mentions the sub's position, and never pretends a silent contract says something it does not. It states a fact, points to the paper or the fair price, and offers the clean route in the same breath, which is the version of this conversation that keeps a client who was merely testing, and prices the exit of one who was not.

Honest limits

This page is general information about handling a direct approach, not legal advice: whether non-circumvention or introduction wording binds a client, and what remedy it carries, depends on the exact words, the place, and the sums, and a large engagement or a clear written breach deserves a lawyer's read before you rely on the clause. If no written term covers the approach, the honest position is the commercial one described here, not an invented breach. A job record proves the engagement facts saved on it, who was engaged for what and when; it cannot prove a client's motive for making an approach, and a verifiable receipt proves the saved result was not changed since it was saved, not what anyone intended.

Step 6. Price the introduction properly and fix the paper for the next job

However this instance resolves, it has priced a lesson: your introductions have market value, and the next job should say so in advance. Add two short clauses to your standard terms. Client side: subcontractors and specialists introduced by your firm are engaged through your firm for a stated period covering the job and a stated number of months after it, or engaged directly on payment of a stated introduction fee, so the client always has a clean, priced route and never needs the back door. Sub side: the sub agrees to route direct approaches from your clients to you, and to tell you when one happens, in exchange for your commitment that reporting is always safe and never punished. Keep both clauses short, priced, and unremarkable, the kind of terms serious firms carry without comment. Then close this instance cleanly in writing: whatever was agreed with the client, routed work or a settled fee or a parting, confirmed in one short message with the record attached, so the resolution sits on paper too. Handled this way, the episode compounds in your favour: subs learn that honesty is safe with you, clients learn your introductions are priced rather than free, and the next approach, if it comes, arrives as a fee conversation instead of a betrayal.

Frequently asked questions

My client tried to hire my subcontractor directly behind my back. What do I do?

Slow down and work in order. First, protect the sub: thank them if they told you, confirm their current work and payment continue exactly as agreed, and make clear that being approached is not something they will be punished for. Second, read what your client agreement and your sub agreement actually say about direct engagement, non-circumvention, and introduction fees, before claiming anything, because the paper decides whether you hold a breach claim, a fee claim, or a commercial conversation. Third, write to the client calmly, anchored in the agreement and in the job record of who was engaged for what and by whom, and offer the clean route: the work run through your firm on the usual terms, or the introduction fee settled. Anger aimed at the sub loses you the wrong relationship, and a breach claim the paper does not support loses you credibility with the client.

Is the client in breach if nothing in our agreement mentions subcontractors?

On the paper alone, probably not in breach of anything, and it matters to be honest with yourself about that before you write. A breach needs a promise, and if neither agreement says anything about direct engagement, introductions, or circumvention, the client has broken an expectation rather than a term. That does not leave you without a move. You hold a commercial conversation: the introduction came through your firm, the working relationship and the job record run through you, and the fair price of taking the sub direct is an introduction fee, which you can propose in the same calm message. Some clients pay it readily once it is framed as the normal price of the introduction. Either way, the durable fix is forward-looking: the clause goes into your standard terms before the next job, so the next approach is governed by paper instead of by anyone's sense of fairness.

Should I confront my subcontractor for talking to the client?

No. Being approached is not misconduct, and treating it as misconduct teaches every sub you work with to hide the next approach from you. The sub you want is the one who tells you, and that behaviour survives only if telling you is safe. Thank the sub who reported it, confirm their work and payment are unaffected, and keep any firmness for the conversation where it belongs, with the client, grounded in the agreements. The one exception is where your sub agreement contains a clear term the sub agreed about direct work from your clients; even then, the conversation is factual and proportionate, about the term you both agreed, and it still starts from the record of what was actually agreed rather than from a sense of personal betrayal.

What if the subcontractor wants to take the direct work?

Then price the situation honestly instead of fighting it. If a written term covers the introduction, settle on its terms: the work routed through you, or the introduction fee paid, confirmed in writing. If no term covers it, you can propose the fee as the fair price of the introduction, and if the client and the sub both decline, your real assets are the relationship and the lesson: keep the sub relationship warm if you can, because a good sub who leaves on decent terms still sends work and warnings your way, and put the introduction clause into your standard terms the same week. What never pays is trying to block two parties who are determined to deal directly, with no paper behind you: it spends your reputation with both of them and buys nothing. Price it, paper it next time, and keep the door you may need later.

How does a job record help when a client goes around me?

It states the factual spine of the conversation as record rather than recollection: this subcontractor, engaged by your firm, for this scope, on these dates, with the work and its acceptance saved step by step. When the work runs through Zambo, built by Brennan Zambo, every job lands on its own record with a verifiable receipt for each step under AER-1, published as IETF Internet-Draft draft-zambo-aer1-26, so who was engaged for what sits on a page you can link in the client message. Every tool free once a day, plus 3 continue calls. One free wrap-up handover per day, and pickup is always free. For $0.99, run the engagement on one record, so the introduction is provable on the day anyone questions it: get the Day Pass. A Day Pass is unlimited for 24 hours, no subscription. Ongoing use is the Zambo Pass at $29 a month, $19 a month for $ZAMBO holders, or Lifetime at $250 one time.

Related